Splurge Vs. Steal

Isabel Marant Tacy Pony Booties / Sam Edelman Margot Booties

I haven't done one of these posts in quite a while, but a couple pieces this season just keep standing out to me as being so incredibly similar. These stiletto boots are so sexy, and the Sam Edelmans are an excellent alternative to the $1,500 Isabel Marants. I've been seeing the Marants all over fashion blogs - they're both super stylish and sleek, but now you can find an almost identical pair for under $250! I almost like the Sam Edelmans better... So which would you do? Splurge or steal?